Hypoxemia, as evidenced by apnea, cyanosis, saturations < 90% or a PaO2 < 60 mm Hg, and hypotension, as evidenced by as a single episode of systolic blood pressure < 90 mm Hg, have been shown to be among the top five predictors of poor outcome in patients with TBI. It is therefore felt to be appropriate to identify and address these conditions as soon as available resources and the tactical situation allow.
Recognizing that assessment and treatment modalities may not be readily available in the forward military environment, the following is but a guide to the level of care that is recommended within certain tactical and operational limitations:
MEDLINE was searched from 1966 to 2005 using the following search terms: "head injury" or "traumatic brain injury" and "airway" or "hypoxemia" or "hypotension" or "oxygenation assessment" or "blood pressure assessment" or "field assessment of oxygenation and blood pressure." References from the book, Guidelines for Prehospital Management of Traumatic Brain Injury, chapter on "Assessment: Oxygenation and Blood Pressure" were also reviewed. Some studies of in-hospital patients with severe head injury and hypotension were used to corroborate out-of-hospital hypotension studies.
Assessment of Oxygenation
The concept of secondary injury is fundamental to understanding the management of TBI. Hypoxia has long been known to be a significant source of secondary brain injury. Significant Class III data have validated the concept that patients with an oxygen saturation < 90% have significantly worse outcome than patients whose oxygen saturations are > 90%.
While it has never been demonstrated that improving blood oxygen saturation in the field improves outcome, a significant body of clinical research seems to support the assertion that this should be so. Knowing that blood oxygen saturation is > 90% is a long way from knowing anything about oxygen delivery to the brain. While the brain's general susceptibility to hypoxia is understood in general terms, the unique susceptibility of the injured brain to hypoxia is very poorly understood.
It is well known that the brain has very little cellular or tissue oxygen reserve and so is highly dependent on timely delivery of oxygen via the circulation. In general, the brain can only survive for 7 minutes without oxygen before the threat of irreversible cellular damage becomes very high. The cellular physiology of this process has been investigated, as have the biochemical consequences of low oxygen availability and ATP depletion in nerve cells. Nerve cells, glial cells, and cerebral vascular endothelium all appear to have unique susceptibilities to low oxygen tension, and so it is not surprising that patients with low oxygen saturation in the blood after injury may fair worse.
Clinical studies in humans have demonstrated that patients with less oxygen delivered to their brain after injury appear to have worse outcomes.
One method for assessing the adequacy of the brain's oxygen delivery is to measure how much oxygen the brain uses. This can be estimated by knowing the oxygen content of the blood entering the cranial vault, the systemic oxygen content, and then measuring the content of the blood leaving the cranial vault, which is done by placing a sensor or sampling catheter high in the jugular vein. By subtracting the oxygen content of the blood leaving the head from the content of the blood entering the head, a rough estimate of the brain oxygen utilization can be obtained. The resulting number is known as the AVO2 difference.
This number reflects the balance between the oxygen delivered to the brain and the metabolic activity, and therefore the oxygen demand, of the brain. A metabolically active brain will require more oxygen and more delivery of oxygen than a quiet brain. The brain will be injured when this demand is not met. The AVO2 difference really assesses if brain demand is being met.
The AVO2 difference is useful, but some estimates of the adequacy of oxygen delivery to the brain can be made by simply measuring the saturation of blood leaving the brain in the jugular bulb, the SjvO2. Most patients have saturations of 55-69% in blood leaving the brain. Studies have shown that patients with jugular saturations < 50% have worse outcomes.
The real issue, however, is cerebral tissue oxygen tension. This can be measured via cerebral tissue oxygen monitoring. Normal cerebral tissue oxygen pressures, PbrO2, are approximately 32 mm Hg. Studies have shown that patients whose PbrO2 is allowed to dip to 15 or lower do significantly worse. Elegant work has stratified patients into groups with episodes of progressively lower brain tissue oxygen pressures, with increasingly poorer outcomes as the brain tissue oxygen pressure is allowed to go lower and the time the brain stays at these suppressed levels increases.
Assessment of Blood Pressure
The assessment of blood pressure follows much the same logic as that for assessment of oxygen. The ultimate problem appears to be the delivery of adequate supplies of oxygen and other substrate to the brain after injury. For adequate supplies of oxygen to reach the brain, the blood must be well oxygenated, the saturations give some indication of this, and cerebral blood flow must be adequate. While systemic blood pressure is a poor way to assess cerebral blood flow, it is not unreasonable to assume that patients with low systemic blood pressure are at higher risk for low cerebral blood flow and so should be at higher risk for poor outcomes.
In fact, good epidemiologic data has demonstrated that patients with low systolic pressure have poorer outcomes from head injury than patients who are not permitted to have their systolic blood pressure dip below 90 mm Hg.
Manley et al.
In his analysis of the prospectively collected National Trauma Coma Data Bank data, Chesnut et al.
A smaller Class III study from Australia also found the hypotension and hypoxemia were significant predictors of mortality.
A single episode of hypotension was associated with a doubling of mortality and an increased morbidity when compared with a matched group of patients without hypotension (Table A). Notably, the TCDB study defined hypotension and hypoxemia as a single reported incidence that meets the definition of each and does not require a protracted duration for secondary insult.
Patients with hypoxemia or hypotension have poorer outcomes from TBI than patients who avoid these conditions. It would therefore seem appropriate to correct these conditions as soon as resources and tactical situation allow.
A structured and prioritized approach to combat casualties is important because it enables a clear assessment process for the medic to follow. We acknowledge the Advanced Trauma Life Support Course™ of the Committee on Trauma of the American College of Surgeons.
| Reference | Data Class | Description of Study | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chesnut, 1993 | III | A prospective study of 717 severe head injury patients admitted consecutively to four centers investigated the effect on outcome of hypotension (systolic blood pressure [SBP] < 90 mm Hg) occurring from injury through resuscitation. | Hypotension was a statistically independent predictor of outcome. A single episode of hypotension during this period doubled mortality and also increased morbidity. Patients whose hypotension was not corrected in the field had a worse outcome than those whose hypotension was corrected by time of emergency department arrival. |
| Fearnside, 1993 | III | A prospective study of 315 severe head injury patients admitted consecutively to a single-center investigated prehospital and inhospital predictors of outcome. | Hypotension (SBP < 90 mm Hg) occurring at any time during a patient's course independently predicts worse outcome. |
| Gentleman, 1992 | III | A retrospective study of 600 severe head injury patients in three cohorts evaluated regarding the influence of hypotension on outcome and the effect of improved prehospital care in decreasing its incidence and negative impact. | Improving prehospital management decreased the incidence of hypotension but its impact on outcome in patients suffering hypotensive insults maintained as a statistically significant, independent predictor of poor outcome. Management strategies that prevent or minimize hypotension in the prehospital phase improves outcome from severe head injury. |
| Gopinath, 1999 | III | SjvO2 and PbtO2 were successfully monitored in 58 patients with severe head injury. The changes in SjvO2 and PbtO2 were compared during ischemic episodes. | Both monitors provide complimentary information, and neither monitor alone identifies all episodes of ischemia. The best strategy for using these monitors is to take advantage of the unique features of each monitor. SjvO2 should be used as a monitor of global oxygenation; but PbtO2 should be used as a monitor of local oxygenation, ideally with the catheter placed in an area of the brain that is vulnerable to ischemia but that may be salvageable with appropriate treatment. |
| Hill, 1993 | III | Retrospective study of the prehospital and emergency department resuscitative management of 40 consecutive multi-trauma patients. Hypotension (SBP = 80 mm Hg) correlated strongly with fatal outcomes. Hemorrhagic hypovolemia was the major etiology of hypotension. | Improving the management of hypovolemic hypotension is a major potential mechanism for improving the outcome from severe head injury. |
| Jeffreys, 1981 | III | A retrospective review of hospital records of 190 head injury patients who died after admission. Hypotension was one of the four most common avoidable factors correlated with death. | Early hypotension appears to be a common and avoidable cause of death in severe head injury patients. |
| Kohi, 1984 | III | A retrospective evaluation of 67 severe head injury patients seen over a 6-month period was correlated with 6-month outcome. For a given level of consciousness, the presence of hypotension resulted in a worse outcome than would have been predicted. | Early hypotension increases the mortality and worsens the prognosis of survivors in severe head injury. |
| Kokoska, 1998 | III | A retrospective review of 72 pediatric patients (ages 3 months-14 years) with regard to hypotensive episodes and outcome. Hypotensive episode was defined as a blood pressure reading of less than the fifth percentile for age that lasted longer than 5 minutes. | Prehospital, ED, and ICU hypotensive episodes were significantly associated with poor outcome. |
| Miller, 1982 | III | 225 severe head injury patients were prospectively studied with respect to the influence of secondary insults on outcome. Hypotension (SBP < 95 mm Hg) was significantly associated with increased morbidity and mortality. The predictive independence of hypotension in comparison with other associated factors, however, was not investigated. | Strong statistical relationship between early hypotension and increased morbidity and mortality from severe head injury. |
| Miller, 1978 | III | 100 consecutive severe head injury patients were prospectively studied with respect to the influence of secondary insults on outcome (report of first 100 patients in subsequent report of 225 patients [vide supra]). Hypotension (SBP < 95 mm Hg) associated with a trend (not statistically significant) toward worse outcome in entire cohort; the trend met statistical significance for patients without mass legions. Seminal report relating early hypotension to increased morbidity and mortality. Influence of hypotension on outcome was not analyzed independently from other associated factors. | First prospective report implicating early hypotension as a major predictor of increased morbidity and mortality from severe head injury. |
| Obrist, 1984 | III | Cohort study of 31 patients with severe TBI in whom the effect of aggressive hyperventilation on ICP, CBF, and arteriovenous difference in oxygen content (AVdO2) was examined. | Hyperventilation had a much more direct effect on CBF reduction (29 of 31 patients) than it did on ICP reduction (15 of 31 patients). Aggressive hyperventilation in 10 patients (PaCO2) of 23.2 ± 2.8 mm Hg) led to AVdO2 values of 10.5 ± 0.7 vol% and CBF values of 18.6 ± 4.4ml/100 g/min. |
| Pigula, 1993 | III | 58 children (< 17 years old) with severe head injuries were prospectively studied for the effect of hypotension (SBP < 90 mm Hg) on outcome. An episode of hypotension decreased survival fourfold. This finding was confirmed in a concomitant analysis of the effect of hypotension on outcome in 509 patients in the National Pediatric Trauma Registry. Hypotension appeared to eliminate any neuroprotective mechanisms normally afforded by age. | The detrimental effects of hypotension (SBP < 90 mm Hg) on outcome appear to extend to children. |
| Robertson, 1989 | III | 51 patients who were comatose due to head injury, subarachnoid hemorrhage, or cerebrovascular disease. CBF was measured daily for 3-5 days, and in 49 patients CBF was measured every 8 hours for 5-10 days after injury. | These studies suggest that reliable estimates of CBF may be made from AVdO2 and AVDL measurements, which can be easily obtained in the intensive care unit. |
| Stocchetti, 1996 | III | A prospective study of data collected at the accident scene from 50 severely head-injured patients rescued by helicopter. Instead of classifying blood pressure or oxygen saturation measurements as above or below a certain threshold, systolic blood pressure was classified as < 60 mm Hg, 60-80 mm Hg, 81-99 mm Hg, or > 99 mm Hg, and arterial oxygen saturation measured via pulse oximeter was classified as < 60%, 60-80%, 81-90%, or > 90%. Patients with lower blood pressure or oxygen saturation fared worse than those with higher values. | Low prehospital blood pressures or oxygen saturations are associated with worse outcomes. Arterial oxygen saturation of 80% or lower was associated with a 47% mortality compared with 15% mortality when oxygen saturation was greater than 80%. |
| Valadka, 1998 | III | Forty-three severely head-injured patients who were not obeying commands on presentation or whose condition deteriorated to this level shortly after admission had intracerebral placement of Licox (n = 39) or Paratrend (n = 4) PO2 probes during craniotomy or in the intensive care unit. | Both the Licox and Paratrend probes functioned well in room air and in the Level I control. However, in the zero-oxygen solution, the Paratrend probes gave an average reading of 7.0 ± 1.4 torr (0.9 ± 0.2 kPa), compared with 0.3 ± 0.3 torr (0.04 ± 0.04 kPa) for the Licox probes. Analysis of the PbtO2 monitoring data suggested that the likelihood of death increased with increasing duration of time at or below a PbtO2 of 15 torr (2.0 kPa) or with the occurrence of any PbtO2 values of ≤ 6 torr (≤ 0.8 kPa). |
| Winchell, 1996 | III | From a trauma registry of 1013 patients, 157 patients with severe anatomic head injury (i.e., Head and Neck Abbreviated Injury Scale Score of 4 or 5) were identified. These included 88 patients with Glasgow Coma Scale score > 8. The 157 patients had a total of 831 episodes of systolic hypotension (< 100 mm Hg) while in the ICU. The total number and the average daily number of hypotensive events were independent predictors of death in the ICU. | Transient hypotensive (systolic BP < 100 mm Hg) episodes in the ICU are associated with a significantly worse outcome. Mortality rose from 9-25% in patients who had 1-10 hypotensive episodes and in 35% in patients with > 10 episodes. |